Should Your Nonprofit Ask Donors to Cover Credit Card Processing Fees?

Chris Esh

20250516_1036_Watercolor Online Shopping_remix_01jvcra7arf7btmcnpq5k734bd

Many of my nonprofit clients often ask me if we can include an option on their donation forms asking donors to add 3% to cover the credit card fees.

Credit card fees do add up, no doubt. I know it feels like lost money that goes to a bank instead of you. But it’s a bad idea to ask donors to cover their fees.

Here’s why:

  • Remember, donors are giving you FREE MONEY. They are giving you something valuable and asking for nothing in return.
  • To guilt them into adding an additional 3% to the arbitrary amount they offered to donate makes you appear unappreciative of their gift.
  • It puts focus on monetary transaction, making donors think about money rather than impact. And when people think too much about money, about their credit card, etc., it brings up negative feelings which could cause some to stop before completing the donation.
  • Some donors will feel a “way” about being told they should donate 3% more than whatever amount they generously just offered to give. And the subtle suggestion that they’re cheap if they’re willing to donate $100 but aren’t willing to cover the credit card fees.
  • It’s really no different from asking donors to add 3% to their donation to help cover your expensive rent or increased cost of employee benefits.

I doubt it makes a big difference either way. I’m sure many donors choose to cover the fees, but I suspect that’s offset by the occasional donor opting out because they feel unappreciated. You can easily measure the money that comes in from asking for this additional 3%, but it’s hard to accurately measure the donors that opt-out because of this practice.

Better alternatives to asking donors to cover fees

1. Build processing costs into your fundraising budget

The most straightforward approach is to simply accept payment processing as a standard cost of doing business. Just as you budget for staff, rent, and utilities, include payment processing in your operational expenses. This is the cleanest approach from a donor experience perspective.

2. Focus on average donation size instead

Rather than fixating on recovering that 3%, put your energy into increasing average donation amounts through better storytelling, impact reporting, and donor cultivation. Moving your average donation from $75 to $80 will more than offset processing fees without creating friction in the giving process.

3. Offer fee-free payment options prominently

If processing fees truly impact your budget, highlight ACH/bank transfer options which typically have much lower fees. Just be careful not to make credit card donors feel like they’re making a “worse” choice.

4. Charge enough for events and merchandise to cover fees

When setting prices for events and merchandise, build in a buffer to cover processing fees. Rather than pricing an item at $100 and adding fees, set the price at $105 to account for all costs. This creates a cleaner, more transparent pricing structure that won’t surprise or frustrate your supporters.

The psychology of giving matters

Remember that donation decisions are often emotional rather than purely rational. The giving experience should feel good from start to finish. Any element that creates hesitation, confusion, or negative feelings can derail a donation that was about to happen.

When donors feel appreciated and see their giving as simple and frictionless, they’re more likely to:

  • Complete their donation
  • Increase their gift amount
  • Return for future giving
  • Recommend your organization to others

The bottom line

While the 3% fee coverage option might seem like an easy way to recapture costs, the potential downsides to donor experience likely outweigh the financial benefits. Instead, focus on creating a seamless, positive giving experience that encourages generosity and long-term donor relationships.

Your organization’s sustainability doesn’t hinge on recovering transaction fees—it depends on building a loyal, engaged donor base that feels good about supporting your mission.

West Philadelphia Victorian House Jan 14 2025

Join our email list!

Tips and tricks to bring your marketing inline with your values, delivered to your inbox.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.